Livio Bucci
https://www.facebook.com/tatami.shiatsu
Namikoshi and Masunaga Shiatsu:
To the classic, though somewhat vague, question often asked by users: “What type of Shiatsu do you practice?”, this is a helpful and concise answer.
The Namikoshi Shiatsu and Masunaga Shiatsu (Zen Shiatsu) schools are two of the main styles of Japanese Shiatsu. Both are based on the concept of pressure applied with the hands to rebalance the body’s energy, but they differ significantly on both technical and cultural and philosophical levels.
Below is a summary of the differences and similarities between the two:
Similarities:
Japanese Origins: Both originated in Japan in the 20th century.
Use of the Hands: The fingers (thumbs) and palms are primarily used to apply pressure.
Therapeutic Purpose: Both seek to stimulate the body’s self-healing capacity and restore energetic balance.
Presence of the Concept of “Ki” (Vital Energy): Although in different ways, both refer to the flow of vital energy.
Comprehensive Treatment: Treatment involves the entire body, although with different approaches.
Differences:
Founder: The founder of the Namikoshi style was Tokujiro Namikoshi (in the 1920s), while the founder of the Masunaga style was Shizuto Masunaga (in the 1960s).
Philosophical View: The Namikoshi style has a more Western and scientific approach, focusing on muscles, nerves, and reflexes. The Masunaga style has an Eastern and holistic approach, integrated with Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM).
Energy Theory: Namikoshi Shiatsu does not explicitly use energy meridian theory. Masunaga Shiatsu uses an expanded meridian system (different from classical Chinese meridians), with psychophysical connections.
Diagnosis: The Namikoshi style uses a diagnosis based on physical palpation (physical symptoms, stiffness, tension). The Masunaga style includes an energetic diagnosis (Hara, pulses, observation), which includes emotional and mental diagnoses.
Technique: With Namikoshi, localized vertical pressure is applied to specific points, sometimes comparable to acupuncture without needles. With Masunaga, a fluid and continuous treatment is performed, following the meridians: often a deeper and more dynamic approach.
Therapist Movement: In Namikoshi Shiatsu, less emphasis is placed on fluid body movement. In Masunaga Shiatsu, greater attention is paid to natural movement (undulation) and the connection between the body and the therapist.
Relationship with the Patient: With Namikoshi Shiatsu, the relationship is more therapeutic and clinical. With Masunaga Shiatsu, an empathic and interactive relationship is established: the therapist adapts to the patient’s energy.
Treatment Goal: The Namikoshi style is specifically aimed at relieving pain and muscle tension (a symptomatic approach). The Masunaga style seeks global energetic harmonization (a holistic approach: mind-body-spirit).
Cultural Aspects:
Cultural Orientation: Namikoshi is modern, influenced by Western medicine. Masunaga is based on Zen philosophy and Eastern medicine.
Values Transmitted: Namikoshi Shiatsu conveys professionalism, scientific rigor, and standardization. Masunaga Shiatsu seeks introspection, listening, empathy, and a holistic view of the human being.
Conclusions:
– The Namikoshi style is best suited for those seeking a rational, physical therapeutic approach.
– The Masunaga style (Zen Shiatsu) is ideal for those seeking a holistic energetic vision and a deeper connection between body, mind, and spirit.
https://www.facebook.com/TatamiShiatsuRoma
https://www.facebook.com/AccademiaItalianaShiatsuDO
https://www.facebook.com/APOS.shiatsu
https://shiatsu-apse.es/ https://www.facebook.com/ShiatsuAPSE/
https://www.facebook.com/www.dreamshiatsu.it/